Thursday, April 23, 2009

Humanitarian intervention

This article will try to clarify the legal status of humanitarian intervention under international law. Most of the ideas obtained were from the conference I attended from 19-22 march at the college of European studies, Natolin(Warsaw). Basically, the conference was sort of an introduction to the various aspects of international humanitarian law under the umbrella of International Law.
I would try to give an overview of the legal status of humanitarian intervention under International Law today.
Inspite of the long history of legal discourse on the matter, there is no consistence consensus as regards the legality of humanitarian intervention under international law. The opponents of formally acknowledging a right of humanitarian intervention often refer to the risk of abuse of the action and, in view of the many so-called humanitarian interventions which have been carried out for reasons of self-interest, this argument can be easily understood. Yet, others argue that situations of grave and systematic human rights violations do justify an intervention for humanitarian reasons and that such situations concerns the international community as a whole. Indeed, during the second half of the 20th century the development within human rights law shows a clear tendency towards a greater international responsibility.
Still, after having studied relevant legislation, case law and legal doctrine, it is my view that legality of humanitarian intervention is restricted to situations where there is prior authorization by the United Nations Security Council. Individual states or a community of states cannot without such prior authorization justify a humanitarian intervention on legal grounds under international law today. The following pages will portray why.
“All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations.” This is the wording of Article 2(4) of the United Nations Charter which is at the center of the debate with respect to the legality of humanitarian interventions.1 Does this provision allow for an intervention by the use of force for humanitarian reasons? Opinions differ immensely on this vexed question.
Still, in spite of the long history of legal discourse concerning humanitarian intervention, there is a lack of consistent consensus (opinio juris communis) under international law. Throughout history and still today there has been a reluctance in formally acknowledging a right of humanitarian intervention out of fear of abuse of the same. On the other hand, there are situations were an intervention for humanitarian reasons may be well founded. Many argue that the United Nations Security Council should have responded earlier to the situation in Rwanda, where the lack of action resulted in genocide. Grave and systematic human rights violations are a concern not solely to the sovereign state in which they are conducted but to the international community as a whole.
In not trying to be called a pessimist though, International humanitarian law has vividly streamlined the policies and structures needed in times of war and after war especially when dealing with combatants, wounded soldiers, prisoners of war, refugees and humanitarian aid. Most of the organizations(International committee of red cross) operating under the umbrella of International humanitarian law has however been useful in assisting the victims of war(both civilians and combatants). Much still has to be done in terms of formulating non discriminating policies.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Life...Life.....Life

What do you first do when you learn to swim? You make mistakes, do you not? And what happens? You make other mistakes, and when you have made all the mistakes you possibly can without drowning - and some of them many times over - what do you find? That you can swim? Well - life is just the same as learning to swim! Do not be afraid of making mistakes, for there is no other way of learning how to live!